Moomah the Magazine
Brooklyn Farmacy

Brooklyn Farmacy

- By Rachel Filler

Being an Australian in New York is not always easy—I get a lot of weird looks and questions: Yes, by “tom-AH-toe” I mean “tom-AY-toe.” No, I didn’t know Steve Irwin, nor have I used a kangaroo as transport around town. I’ve had to learn to live with explanations of my native land, and come to terms with the fact that a lot of people think of Australia as they've seen it portrayed in movies. Recently though, the tables were turned. While planning the Summer Food Issue, Lisel began to tell me about the Farmacy in Brooklyn—a "soda fountain" that serves up “floats”, “egg creams” and “chocolate flavored sodas.” It was my turn to give the weird looks. What's a Soda Fountain? And an Egg Cream? It sounded like something from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. Surely that couldn’t be the type of place she meant?

When we arrived, it was immediately clear that actually, that's exactly what she meant. Stepping in to The Brooklyn Farmacy is like walking onto the set of a movie from the 1920’s. The old original tile floor, patterned and colorful, sets the tone of the place and speaks to its history. The walls are lined with vintage wooden shelves filled with both treats for customers and relics of the era—a reminder that this used to be a place to fill your prescription, not necessarily to gather with friends. The long stretched bar with a mirrored wall and soda on tap were some of the only additions made when deciding that this place would no longer stand as an actual medical pharmacy but instead as a farmacy, where people would come to get a different kind of sugary medicine.


We sat down with Gia Giasallo and Peter Freeman, the brother and sister duo behind the wonder, to get the scoop on The Brooklyn Farmacy, and to hopefully help me understand it all. Though still confused by both the menu items as well as the history and significance of those mysterious empty medicine bottles on the shelves, Gia ensured us that there was a story to tell and she would explain it all. What story-tellers they were. Lisel and I were hooked as Gia began telling a tale of life in the 1920’s when Prohibition began, and the city learned to find new ways to have a good time.

Originally, soda fountains were an attempt to replicate the earth’s natural mineral water which was believed to be able to cure disease. With the discovery of carbonated water, the soda factory business was in full force, and became a sensation across the world, particularly in America. Pharmacies were the most natural place to install these soda fountains as still, most continued to associate carbonated water with health. 


Soon the Soda Fountain came to serve an important function as a public space where neighbors could socialize and exchange community news. Located on street corners, they were used as an opportunity to gather with friends. And eventually, the bar-like feel grew: When prohibition hit and Bartenders lost their jobs, they found themselves behind a new counter at the Soda Fountain. They took on the title of “Soda Jerks” and began mixing different concoctions, creating the fun of these creative drinks, but without the alcohol.

Fast forward to today, the Brooklyn Farmacy is truly a revived relic. The space that the Farmacy inhabits was a functioning Soda Fountain from the 1920's–the peak of American Soda Fountain times– until 1968, when doors were shut. Not much has changed in the space between 1968 and today. Seeing the old shelving and miscellaneous items at the Brooklyn Farmacy, we’re glad Gia and Peter have kept the tradition and this special place alive.

This year marks the fourth summer that the space is up and running, with the revival of the beautifully mixed sodas, the history of the place is still being well honored.

Though owning and running a soda fountain was not a life-long goal for either Gia or Peter. When the two entered the old and dilapidated building for the first time, “the space just spoke to us,” says Gia. “We knew that this was what it had to be and knew we had to pay respect to what the space is.” And that they’ve done. “We try to make the place run as a soda factory would have in the ‘20’s. We even have young teenagers working with us—that’s what they did back in the day—hired kids!”


Gia explains that “this place shows the theatre of life. It’s about the moments that happen here and memories that are made. People really honor this place to the fullest. Parents bring their kids or parents bring their own parents. Either way they come here to have an experience. You don’t see too many people on their phones or iPads. People are having real conversations in real time…that is what people are hungry for, and what we are serving up.”

We could have sat and listened to the stories of the place for most of the day—the struggles, the questions, the light-bulb moments of creativity the space sparked in them—but all of these stories are being stored in preparation for the launch of their first cookbook in Spring 2014. The book, which of course will have many delicious soda recipes, is also set to include the history and stories behind the Brooklyn Farmacy, along with the history of The American Soda Fountain. Stories that will make you appreciate and understand the place so much more. 

While Gia created the brilliant branding, logo and custom packaging for all their baked goods and snacks the Farmacy sells, it is Peter who comes up with all of the items on the menu, works with the staff, and helps to ensure that the place is authentic and fitting with the soda fountain culture.


PETER AND GIA WERE NICE ENOUGH share THE Farmacy'S take on the traditional egg cream. Light, delicious and easy to make. Yum!

Peter told us of his dream to make the best egg creams in Brooklyn, and I felt it was time to sheepishly admit that I still had no idea what an egg cream was! And so, the demonstration was on. Gia fixed us up with "The Violet" - made with Fox's U-bet vanilla syrup, cold seltzer and a scoop of Adirondack Creamery's Black Raspberry Ice Cream. We also tried the "Pink Poodle" (Hibiscus soda and a scoop of vanilla), and a traditional egg cream (image on the right). The sign on the wall reads “If you’ve never had an egg cream before, you’re in for a treat,” and what a treat it was. We had to share a recipe with you to try at home:

Brooklyn Farmacy's BUTTERBEER Egg Cream
c. Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain
What you'll need:
  • 12 ounce glass
  • Iced tea spoon (long handled spoon)
  • 1/4 cup Whipped Cream
  • 1 1/2 ounce Caramel Sauce
  • Steamed milk
  • Seltzer
  1. FILL  glass with fresh whipped cream.
  2. POUR warm caramel sauce.
  3. ADD steamed milk until 1/2" below the top of the glass.
  4. STIR contents.
  5. ADD seltzer until glass is full.



Posted in:

Share |

<< previous article

next article >>

Recent Comments

No one has commented yet... be the first!

Join the conversation!

Subscribe Now

Get each new issue of

Moomah the Magazine

delivered to you every fortnight

For Free!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • RSS
skip to site